Every Time I Die are the first to make it to 500 listens for me.

1 Every Time I Die 500
2 Lostprophets 498
2 36 Crazyfists 498
4 My Chemical Romance 488
5 Winnebago Deal 471
6 Lamb of God 450
7 65daysofstatic 360
8 Silverchair 352
9 Paramore 322
10 Biffy Clyro 315