They've given it 5.2.
Which is good for Noah considering they gave the last record a 2.6. Not long now until they get a 10.4 etc.

I'm a little bit annoyed though because they bash it on merit of the music and the lyrics being really simplistic. Only the Girls album is exactly the same and they somehow managed to squeeze some genius out of "Oh I wish I had a girlfriend, I wish I had a pizza and a bottle of wine".

But yes, different reviewers, subjective, etc. I'll stop sulking.